Menu of Cowboy Star Restaurant And Butcher Shop in Colorado Springs, Colorado, USA

Menu Overview

Cowboy Star Restaurant And Butcher Shop in Colorado Springs stands as a premier steakhouse that seamlessly blends an old-world butcher shop experience with contemporary fine dining. Upon exploring their menu, it’s clear this is a place where quality and craftsmanship meet in every dish.

The heart of their offering lies in expertly prepared steaks like the Center Cut 10oz Bison New York Strip and the Filet Mignon, both cooked to perfection, showcasing rich, savory flavors that linger long after the last bite. The American Wagyu NY Strip, highlighted by diners, stands out as an indulgence worth every penny, striking a balance between marbling and tenderness that defines top-tier beef.

Beyond steaks, Cowboy Star surprises with thoughtfully crafted appetizers and sides. The Charcuterie and Cheese Board offers a robust palette of cured meats and artisan cheeses, perfect for sharing or starting the meal on a refined note. The Baby Iceberg Wedge and Crispy Brussels Sprouts dressed with lemon and honey provide a fresh, vibrant contrast, balancing richness with brightness. Soups like the French Onion deliver warmth and depth with caramelized onions and melted cheese, perfectly steeped in savory broth.

Desserts like the Chocolate Chip Bread Pudding add a comforting finish, rich yet just sweet enough to close the meal gracefully. The bar menu complements the food impeccably; cocktails such as the C Star Manhattan and C Star Sangria offer elegant, nuanced profiles, while their curated list of Scotch and fortified wines—including the renowned Dow's 30 Year Tawny Port and Château de Fargues Sauternes—elevate the after-dinner experience.

Customer reviews emphasize not only the culinary excellence but also the hospitable and attentive service. From servers like Cody and Josh, who demonstrate deep knowledge and genuine care, to hosts fostering a welcoming atmosphere, every staff member contributes to a memorable visit. Special touches like anniversary roses and personalized messages enhance the experience, making Cowboy Star more than just a meal—it becomes an event.

The only minor critique lies in the portion sizes of some sides and seating comfort; however, these are easily overshadowed by the quality of food and warmth of service. Whether it’s a celebratory dinner or a casual happy hour visit featuring standout dishes like GOCHUJANG Marinated Beef Skewers paired with housemade fries, Cowboy Star delivers consistently outstanding flavor and atmosphere.

In essence, Cowboy Star Restaurant And Butcher Shop is a must-visit for steak enthusiasts and food lovers in Colorado Springs. Its marriage of premium meats, well-crafted sides, and exceptional hospitality creates a dining experience both deeply satisfying and authentically inviting.